This is just wrong!!! One of my good friends just returned a few body tools this morning. He borrowed the tools last week when I wasn't home and Mrs. GF just let him into the shop and grab what he needed. No big deal, he's a great friend and helps me out a lot when I need him, but his lack of knowledge showed in this situation.
I keep two sets of basic body tools -- a beater set and a finishing set. The beater tools are inexpensive cast steel and cast iron sets that I've collected over the years and are used exclusively to rough out panels. These tools get dinged and beat on most of the time. I also keep a second set of highly polished hammers and dollies that are quite expensive quality steel forged items. These tools are used exclusively for finishing work on bare metal panels. They have no dings whatsoever and I keep them oiled and clean.
The "beater" section of my toolbox -- low cost hammers and dollies for roughing work
(http://i357.photobucket.com/albums/oo18/goodfellow_2004/misc/PICT0260Medium-1.jpg)
Just a few of my favorite "beater" hammers that get used pretty much on every job I do. They have rough anvil faces and only get "dressed" every few years, but they get the job done. I like these hammers and use them a LOT.
(http://i357.photobucket.com/albums/oo18/goodfellow_2004/misc/PICT0263Medium-1.jpg)
Here are my finishing dolly sets -- yes there are a few Chinese dollies in there (the red colored items), but I put a high polish on these steel forgings and they serve a distinct purpose. They are significantly smaller in size compared to my other dollies so they work better in tight spaces.
(http://i357.photobucket.com/albums/oo18/goodfellow_2004/misc/PICT0259Medium-1.jpg)
The finishing hammer anvils are fully polished
(http://i357.photobucket.com/albums/oo18/goodfellow_2004/misc/PICT0265Medium-1.jpg)
Well, it turns out my buddy grabbed the wrong batch of tools to do some beater work on his MGB. This "used" to be a quality forged steel heel dolly -- now look at it.
(http://i357.photobucket.com/albums/oo18/goodfellow_2004/misc/PICT0261Medium-1.jpg)
(http://i357.photobucket.com/albums/oo18/goodfellow_2004/misc/PICT0262Medium-1.jpg)
Those dings will transfer directly to a bare metal panel -- especially if it's aluminum. This beater vs. finishing tool aspect wasn't known to my friend when he grabbed the tools. He just opened a drawer and grabbed tools. Luckily he didn't grab a finishing hammer in the process.
So, now I'm separating all the finishing body tools in their own drawer and will keep the tools wrapped up in their own protective pouch -- tube socks!!! I urge all of you to do the same. Keep them separate and protected. Cut one tube sock in half and it will make two excellent pouches.
(http://i357.photobucket.com/albums/oo18/goodfellow_2004/misc/PICT0267Medium-1.jpg)
(http://i357.photobucket.com/albums/oo18/goodfellow_2004/misc/PICT0268Medium-1.jpg)
(http://i357.photobucket.com/albums/oo18/goodfellow_2004/misc/PICT0269Medium-1.jpg)
My buddy feels bad enough, but it's also my fault. I used to keep the finishing body hammers and dollies in a separate locked box and in protective socks, but since I'm doing a lot of metal work these days, I decided to put them together with all my other body tools -- bad idea, and lesson learned.
As they say..."that'll buff out!" but it does look pretty deep. OUCH!!!
https://youtu.be/jWQgXyc39dI?si=epWvlqJMAW8DwZzL
I never knew a guy could "fix" hammer heads and dolleys but this vid showed me I needed to massage a bunch of my tools to get them in TOP shape.
Sorry you got the short end of that, hope you can get them squared away.